First time here?

Go register NOW! It is FREE.
Social Bookmarking on Facebook

Social Traffic Club

Twitter Search Engine


http://www.wikio.com

You don't need followers to make money with Twitter

A few weeks ago I wrote a blog post about the importance of followers on Twitter. I made my case claiming that you don’t need a lot of followers to be successful. I realized that I was going against the grain of what is generally accepted. The reasoning is that the more followers you have the more people can help you spread the word for you. Sounds great, but is that really what is happening?

I had a hard time believing it, because I never personally watch my twitter stream. And I don’t have nearly as many followers as others do. The reactions from my readers were very interesting. Some agreed, others were not so sure. I talked to several in person, and some admitted to getting a kick out of getting more followers.

I believe that that is more a reason to get followers than anything else. You can brag about how popular you are. After all, you have this massive group of fans on your Twitter page. I know that you can have great conversations on Twitter, but in my experience as soon as you are interested in talking to a person more, you take it away from Twitter to a place where you can express yourself in more than 140 characters at a time.

You can probably tell, that I was not convinced to change my opinion based on the input I received. The opposite is more true. I wanted to actually proof my point. So, I decided to set up a brand new Twitter account and to test my hypothesis. I opened an account, put up a fake picture and started following 12 people so my account did not look entirely dead.

As you can see 2 people started following me back. Not anything to brag about. I started tweeting some general tweets from other peoples blogs and I send out some replies to tweets with an affiliate link to a product in it.  There were 12 people that clicked on my Tweets and I made one sale, 23 dollars and 45 cents. I know, not anything to write home about. Except that I opened my Twitter account yesterday, did not do anything special and did not spend a dime in the process.

Obviously, it did not take any followers to achieve this. I was able to reach my target group without worrying about followers. I did not even have a group of people with like interests to count upon. Nothing. Just me and my account. I hope this makes you think a little more, if you are spending time to find people to follow or if you are worried about not having enough followers compared to someone else.

I know that there is a lot of re-tweeting going on. People say that that helps spread the word. But here again, I wonder how it helps. Because if you are not specifically searching for something, how are you going to find these tweets? It is still a needle in a hay stack. Same problem as with the original message.

Take a good look at your twitter stream. How long does a message stay on the front page of your Twitter account. And that is only relevant if you are sitting in front of your computer all day watching the messages. I know, not a realistic scenario. The more I think about it, backed by my little experiment, the more I am convinced that Twitter’s power is in the real time search and not in anything else.

Let me know what you think. Why are you using Twitter. To make money? To build relationships? How often does it happen that you have a conversation on Twitter because you stumbled upon a tweet from someone who follows you? And is this worth any time to build up your army of followers? As always, I am interested in your opinion. Whether you agree or disagree. Share it in the comments.

  • http://controlemotionsafterabreakup.com Anonymous

    Hi Karin,

    Interesting experiment you conducted. As far as my use, I have mostly to this point been using Twitter to create conversations and relationships that I eventually lead away from Twitter because of the 140 character limitation. I recently heard someone who markets specifically for social media state that their reason for encouraging you to gain followers is that it gives you credibility; kind of like if everyone else is following you then you must have something going on. Not sure if I buy that however. What do you think?

    • social bookmarking

      Hi Debbie, thanks for your input. Great question. My view is that if you can only achieve credibility by having more followers than someone else, that credibility does not hold much value. Now, if this person gets a kick out of adding followers, than by all means they should do so. I am simply saying that if you have a business, adding followers is not going to contribute to your bottom line, so spending time on it may not be the way to go.

  • debbiestevens

    Hi Karin,Interesting experiment you conducted. As far as my use, I have mostly to this point been using Twitter to create conversations and relationships that I eventually lead away from Twitter because of the 140 character limitation. I recently heard someone who markets specifically for social media state that their reason for encouraging you to gain followers is that it gives you credibility; kind of like if everyone else is following you then you must have something going on. Not sure if I buy that however. What do you think?

  • Edward

    Hi Karin,

    Great experiment. I agree that twitter is more of a real time search engine that anything else. I have used the tools I have to filter out what I want to read and see. I almost never look at the twitter feed.
    I agree that most people with a mass number of followers are doing it for the game more than anything else. For me I have a group of people who us it for chatting and I chat with them there.

    Make it a great day!
    God Bless,
    -ed

    • social bookmarking

      Hey Ed, great to read that you agree with me. That means a lot to me.

  • http://bookmarksandvotes.com Edward

    Hi Karin,Great experiment. I agree that twitter is more of a real time search engine that anything else. I have used the tools I have to filter out what I want to read and see. I almost never look at the twitter feed.I agree that most people with a mass number of followers are doing it for the game more than anything else. For me I have a group of people who us it for chatting and I chat with them there.Make it a great day!God Bless,-ed

  • Christine Casey

    Hi Karin,

    I really like your experiment…how cool! Personally, I feel the amount of followers is not as important as me being able to interact with them…isn’t that what its all about? I have made some great connections with people that I met thru Twitter, and know that this would not have happened elsewhere, so I do believe in the power of Twitter, you just have to figure out how best to utilize it for your own personal business strategy. Thanks for sharing this information…I always look forward to your posts to see what new something I can learn about ;-) Christine

    • social bookmarking

      Hey Christine, thank you for your kind words. I value Twitter, just like you. I believe that you can find some great people there. I am just making the point that your chances of finding them are much higher through (real time) search than by following them or have them follow you. The experiment pretty much confirmed my statement.

  • http://socialtrafficmastermind.com Christine Casey

    Hi Karin,I really like your experiment…how cool! Personally, I feel the amount of followers is not as important as me being able to interact with them…isn't that what its all about? I have made some great connections with people that I met thru Twitter, and know that this would not have happened elsewhere, so I do believe in the power of Twitter, you just have to figure out how best to utilize it for your own personal business strategy. Thanks for sharing this information…I always look forward to your posts to see what new something I can learn about ;-) Christine

  • Val Wilcox

    Great experiment. I don’t watch all the tweets of my followers or followees either. I have selected the friends and associates who I am interested in interacting with. You bring up some really good points. The numbers don’t matter that much as the personal relationships you can build from.

    Val :)

    • http://bookmarksandvotes.com social bookmarking

      Thanks for your input Val. You are so right, it is all about the people, not about the numbers.

  • Val Wilcox

    Great experiment. I don't watch all the tweets of my followers or followees either. I have selected the friends and associates who I am interested in interacting with. You bring up some really good points. The numbers don't matter that much as the personal relationships you can build from. Val :)

  • Angel Taylor

    I completely agree with you you Karin that it’s not necessarily about the amount of followers you have. I’ve got a little over 8,000 or so on mine and to be honest, I can’t keep up with even half of that amount. Plus, like you said, if I strike up a conversation with someone, I tend to move it over to facebook. It’s much easier to connect when you’re not limited to 140 characters!

    Angel

    • social bookmarking

      Hey Angel, nice to see you here. Thanks for your input also. It is great to see that so many do agree with me. When I researched this I could not find too many that would agree.

  • Angel Taylor

    I completely agree with you you Karin that it's not necessarily about the amount of followers you have. I've got a little over 8,000 or so on mine and to be honest, I can't keep up with even half of that amount. Plus, like you said, if I strike up a conversation with someone, I tend to move it over to facebook. It's much easier to connect when you're not limited to 140 characters!Angel

  • http://bookmarksandvotes.com social bookmarking

    Hey Angel, nice to see you here. Thanks for your input also. It is great to see that so many do agree with me. When I researched this I could not find too many that would agree.

  • social bookmarking

    Thanks for your input Val. You are so right, it is all about the people, not about the numbers.

  • social bookmarking

    Hey Christine, thank you for your kind words. I value Twitter, just like you. I believe that you can find some great people there. I am just making the point that your chances of finding them are much higher through (real time) search than by following them or have them follow you. The experiment pretty much confirmed my statement.

  • http://controlemotionsafterabreakup.com social bookmarking

    Hey Ed, great to read that you agree with me. That means a lot to me.

  • http://socialnetworkvoter.com social bookmarking

    Hi Debbie, thanks for your input. Great question. My view is that if you can only achieve credibility by having more followers than someone else, that credibility does not hold much value. Now, if this person gets a kick out of adding followers, than by all means they should do so. I am simply saying that if you have a business, adding followers is not going to contribute to your bottom line, so spending time on it may not be the way to go.

  • Carstarphen

    Hey Karin,
    You have a killer blog! It seems like I have been here before but I am gonna go ahead and add it to my favorites and join your email list so that I can be sure to visit often. Thanks for putting out this great content.

    J
    Make Money Fast

    • social bookmarking

      Hey Jeremiah, thanks for your kind words. I am glad to hear that you get value out of my posts.

  • Carstarphen

    Hey Karin,You have a killer blog! It seems like I have been here before but I am gonna go ahead and add it to my favorites and join your email list so that I can be sure to visit often. Thanks for putting out this great content.JMake Money Fast

  • Anonymous

    Karin, I love your articles about Twitter. I love tweeting and you remind me to focus on some areas that it’s easy to lose sight of. I’m going to re-assess the way I tweet, what links I use, their relevance etc. Great post .. thanks for this.

    Joanna :)

    • social bookmarking

      Hi Joanna, thanks for visiting. I love Twitter also. It is a very powerful tool if you use it correctly.

  • JoannaSayers

    Karin, I love your articles about Twitter. I love tweeting and you remind me to focus on some areas that it's easy to lose sight of. I'm going to re-assess the way I tweet, what links I use, their relevance etc. Great post .. thanks for this.Joanna :)

  • social bookmarking

    Hi Joanna, thanks for visiting. I love Twitter also. It is a very powerful tool if you use it correctly.

  • http://controlemotionsafterabreakup.com social bookmarking

    Hey Jeremiah, thanks for your kind words. I am glad to hear that you get value out of my posts.

  • Lesly

    Hi Karin,
    I must admit, I have a twitter account and I don’t know what to do with it, or how to use it.. I am almost up to 1,000! That’s a lot for me. But I have a following but what do you do with them…?I really don’t know why I have a twitter account … now I have to go think about it! :-) You write the most informative things about the internet!

    • social bookmarking

      Hey Lesly, Twitter can be a great source of traffic. There are two ways to go about it. One is to regularly send out tweets regarding your topic. The only rule to keep in mind is not to just send promotions for your own (affiliate) products. The other option is to do a Twitter search to find people with problems you can solve. You want to start a conversation with those people.
      Just to give you an indication. My experiment is now 4 days old and I have had 200 visits to my site from sending out some tweets. That is how effective this method can be.
      Lesly, I hope this helps you some. Let me know if you have other questions I might be able to help you with.

  • Lesly

    Hi Karin,I must admit, I have a twitter account and I don't know what to do with it, or how to use it.. I am almost up to 1,000! That's a lot for me. But I have a following but what do you do with them…?I really don't know why I have a twitter account … now I have to go think about it! :-) You write the most informative things about the internet!

  • Pingback: Cobbinaloic's Blog

  • social bookmarking

    Hey Lesly, Twitter can be a great source of traffic. There are two ways to go about it. One is to regularly send out tweets regarding your topic. The only rule to keep in mind is not to just send promotions for your own (affiliate) products. The other option is to do a Twitter search to find people with problems you can solve. You want to start a conversation with those people. Just to give you an indication. My experiment is now 4 days old and I have had 200 visits to my site from sending out some tweets. That is how effective this method can be.Lesly, I hope this helps you some. Let me know if you have other questions I might be able to help you with.

  • http://bookmarksandvotes.com Loic

    I did open a twitter account, but that is just because i wanted to syndicate my website and other people’s websites in my tribe. I have been hearing people do make money on twitter, i have never tried it myself.

  • Loic

    I did open a twitter account, but that is just because i wanted to syndicate my website and other people's websites in my tribe. I have been hearing people do make money on twitter, i have never tried it myself.

  • Elinor

    Makes me think. For me, the beauty of Twitter is possibility. Twitter makes it possible to connect with hot shots as well as colleagues in far away places. Next time you teach a teleseminar on using Twitter please include me.

  • http://socialnetworkvoter.com Elinor

    Makes me think. For me, the beauty of Twitter is possibility. Twitter makes it possible to connect with hot shots as well as colleagues in far away places. Next time you teach a teleseminar on using Twitter please include me.

    • http://controlemotionsafterabreakup.com Karin

      Hi Elinor, thanks for your input. I agree that interactions with others can be very valuable on Twitter. Adding those people to your list of followers makes a lot of sense. But only for that reason. If you do it so that people can find what you are tweeting about, I don’t agree. Even though this is proclaimed by many. I just don’t see how people find your tweets in your Twitter stream. Enough said, I already made my point in the article. It just frustrates me that there are so many who make the claim that the more followers you have the better, without ever thinking about the how and why of that statement.

  • Linnea

    Hi Karin,

    You make an excellent point about Twitter and people seeing your message. If a message goes out to people with loads of followers, it won’t stay on their stream for very long unless they aren’t following too many others or unless you @ or DM them.

  • http://controlemotionsafterabreakup.com Linnea

    Hi Karin,You make an excellent point about Twitter and people seeing your message. If a message goes out to people with loads of followers, it won't stay on their stream for very long unless they aren't following too many others or unless you @ or DM them.

  • Kathie396

    Hi Karin,

    I just started a twitter account a week ago. I noticed that I get followers doing very little. But I am looking to get clients that will actually spend money. So far that has not happened. How can one make this happen?

    Thanks for any insight you can offer.

    K

    • social bookmarking

      I know, that is why I keep saying that Twitter is not about how many followers you have. I personally use Twitter mostly to actively search for people who have a problem that I can solve. When I find those people I start a conversation and during the course of the conversation I mention the solution I have to offer. This is what I know to work best on Twitter. I hope this helps you. Feel free to ask more questions if this is not specific enough.
      Karin.